This page is written by Rewardfinity
We make Rewardfinity, so read this page as our case for it. We rank only ourselves; the other five apps are grouped by what their own pages say they are for. Every statement about another app comes from its own website, help centre, documentation or app-store listing: Stamp Me, Loopy Loyalty and Square Loyalty read on 22 October 2026 and checked on 26 October; BaristaCard read and checked on 1 November; Per Diem read on 3 November, with its pricing and get-started pages read again on 10 November; BonusQR’s headline was read on 14 October and checked on 30 October. “Not described” means not described on the pages we read, not “they do not offer it”. Everything about Rewardfinity was checked against our source code. We print no plan prices, theirs or ours, and the dollar figures in the examples are illustrative; our pricing page shows the price set for your country. We compare Square Loyalty, the loyalty program, and not the rest of Square.
Six coffee shop loyalty apps, side by side
Rewardfinity first, then the others in the order of the sections below. The last column is our argument; each cell is explained, with its source, further down.
| App | Best for | How you start | Where Rewardfinity is stronger |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rewardfinity | Independent cafés that want a stamp card, a prepaid pack and a Square connection, without building an app | 60-day web trial, no card, no automatic charge | Our first pick |
| Stamp Me | Tap-to-stamp counter devices | 30-day trial from the first published card, no card | Native Square; a prepaid pack as a card type |
| Loopy Loyalty | Stamp cards in the customer’s phone wallet | 15-day trial; a credit card is needed to go live | A prepaid pack as a card type; native Square; 60 days against 15 |
| Square Loyalty | Square sellers who want loyalty in the Square Dashboard | 30-day free trial, for Square sellers | Eight card types against one loyalty program per seller |
| Per Diem | Square cafés that want their own branded ordering app, with loyalty as one module | Paid plans on its pricing page, which describes no trial; its get-started page offers the merchant dashboard free after you connect Square | A stamp card; a counter that works without Square; a stated 60-day trial |
| BaristaCard | A free start at one café | First venue free; its FAQ says forever, not a trial | Points and tiers that are your own program; earning from a Square till or the Shopify app |
Why cafés pick Rewardfinity
1. A stamp card and a prepaid coffee pack on one platform
Rewardfinity has eight card types: stamp card, points, membership, member discount, store credit, coupon, gift card and prepaid pack. A café can choose a stamp card of up to 100 stamps for the daily drink, or a prepaid pack for the regular who buys ten at once: you set the number of uses, up to 500, and the price. You take payment in your own register; Rewardfinity records the balance and every use; it never holds the money. Per Diem and BaristaCard also sell stored value, so we do not claim to be alone in it. Stamp Me’s help centre describes no dedicated prepaid option and suggests a private offer instead, and Loopy Loyalty’s documentation describes a stamp card used as a prepaid card. The digital stamp cards page shows how the cards work, and the coffee shop loyalty guide works the numbers on the card and the reward.
2. Square cafés connect natively
Rewardfinity connects to Square natively: a payment carrying the customer’s email, or a Square customer record with one, earns for that member, and a new email is enrolled. A payment with no email is not matched, so staff scan the member’s QR code instead. Stamp Me’s help centre says it does not integrate with POS systems, and Loopy Loyalty documents Square only through two Zapier automations on a paid Zapier plan. Per Diem’s own pages describe a deeper Square sync than ours: menus, modifiers and orders flow through as well as loyalty points, where Rewardfinity reads payments to earn and enroll. Against Square Loyalty itself the difference is not the till but the cards: Rewardfinity has eight card types, where Square’s developer docs allow one loyalty program per seller. Other tills can post purchases for existing members to a signed inbound webhook; see integrations.
3. Start this week, on the phone behind the counter
Where web plans are on sale, a new workspace starts a 60-day trial with no card and no automatic charge, with reminders 7 days and 1 day before it ends. Staff scan the member’s QR code in a browser on a phone or tablet the café already owns, and customers use a hosted member card in the browser with no app download. Trials elsewhere on this page: 15 days at Loopy Loyalty, with a credit card needed to go live, 30 days at Square Loyalty, and 30 days at Stamp Me from your first published card, where ours starts when the workspace is created. 60 ÷ 15 = 4 times as long as Loopy Loyalty’s, and 60 ÷ 30 = 2 times as long as Square Loyalty’s.
The other five, grouped by what each is built for
Each entry gives what the app says it is for, where we think Rewardfinity does that job better for a café, and who it may suit instead.
Stamp Me: best for tap-to-stamp counter devices
Stamp Me is a digital stamp-card platform: customers tap a StampPod counter device or a Stamp Tag, or use single-use codes. Its help centre says “Stamp Me does not integrate with point of sale systems (POS)”, which its homepage presents as a benefit.
Where Rewardfinity is stronger. A Square café earns from the till natively, where Stamp Me says it does not integrate with POS systems. And a prepaid coffee pack is a card type, where Stamp Me’s help centre describes no dedicated prepaid option and suggests a private offer.
May suit you if customers tapping a device at the counter is the experience you want. Rewardfinity and Stamp Me compared.
Loopy Loyalty: best for stamp cards in the customer’s wallet
Loopy Loyalty sells digital stamp cards delivered as Apple Wallet and Google Wallet passes. Its help centre says a card holds up to 30 stamps.
Where Rewardfinity is stronger. A prepaid pack is a card type, where Loopy Loyalty’s documentation describes a stamp card used as a prepaid card. Square is native, where Loopy Loyalty’s help centre documents it only through two Zapier automations on a paid Zapier plan. A stamp card can run to 100 stamps against 30. And the trial is 60 days against 15.
May suit you if a stamp card in the customer’s wallet is all you need. Rewardfinity and Loopy Loyalty compared.
Square Loyalty: best for Square sellers who want loyalty in the Square Dashboard
Square Loyalty is Square’s own loyalty add-on, for sellers on Square Point of Sale or Square Online. Customers earn by visits, spend or items, and Square’s help centre calls a visit program a “virtual punch card”.
Where Rewardfinity is stronger. Eight card types, where Square’s developer docs allow one loyalty program per seller. A café that wants more than one kind of card has a choice of eight in Rewardfinity, among them stamp cards, points with tiers, store credit and prepaid packs.
May suit you if every sale already runs through Square and one program is enough. Rewardfinity and Square Loyalty compared.
Per Diem: best for Square cafés that want their own ordering app
Per Diem builds a branded ordering app for each café that runs on Square. Its homepage says it gives a restaurant “a custom mobile app, website, loyalty program, and marketing tools, all powered by the Square setup you already use”. Its loyalty runs through Square Loyalty or its own points engine, and its pages list store-credit plans with a load bonus, subscriptions and gift cards.
Where Rewardfinity is stronger. A stamp card: Per Diem’s loyalty pages describe points, tiers, streaks and games, not a stamp card; a visit-based points rule is the nearest thing. A counter that works without Square: Per Diem is built for Square and its pages describe no other POS, while Rewardfinity also runs at a counter by QR on a phone you own, and other tills can post purchases for existing members to a signed webhook. And a trial stated up front: Rewardfinity’s is 60 days with no card, where Per Diem’s pricing page lists paid plans and describes no trial. Its get-started page says “Connect your Square POS to experience your full merchant dashboard free”, with no length stated.
May suit you if you run on Square and want your own branded ordering app, online ordering and marketing in one product.
BaristaCard: best for a free start at one café
BaristaCard is free for a café’s first venue and sells prepaid product cards and subscriptions through the app. Its points, Coffee Beans, are shared across participating cafés, and scratch cards and leaderboards are built in.
Where Rewardfinity is stronger. Points and tiers that are your own program, and earning from a Square till or the Shopify app, which BaristaCard’s pages do not describe.
May suit you if you want to start free at one café, with games and subscriptions.
Two other apps come up in cafés and are covered elsewhere: BonusQR, whose headline is “No POS Needed” (compared here), and the wider field in the best loyalty apps for small business. For a stamp-card-only view, see the best digital punch card apps.
A café’s two best-sellers, app by app
The stamp card and the prepaid pack, then the two ways sales reach them: a Square till and an online store. Rewardfinity is not ahead on every row, and the chart shows where it is not.
| App | Stamp card | Prepaid coffee pack | Earns from a Square till | Earns from an online store |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rewardfinity | ● Up to 100 stamps | ● Up to 500 uses; payment taken in your own register | ◐ Native: a payment with an email earns; with none, staff scan the member’s QR | ● The Shopify app: points, in its own workspace |
| Stamp Me | ● Stamp cards | ◐ No dedicated option; a private offer instead | ○ Does not integrate with POS, it says | – Not described; single-use codes or manual stamps |
| Loopy Loyalty | ● Up to 30 stamps | ◐ A stamp card used as a prepaid card | ◐ Two Zapier automations, paid Zapier plan | – Shopify is named only as reachable through Zapier |
| Square Loyalty | ● A visit program, a “virtual punch card” | ● Square’s own | ● For Square Online sellers | |
| Per Diem | – Points, tiers, streaks and games; a stamp card is not described, a visit-based points rule is the nearest thing | ● Store-credit plans with a load bonus; subscriptions | ● Square Loyalty, synced | ● Web and app orders earn |
| BaristaCard | ● Stamp cards | ● Prepaid product cards and subscriptions | – Not described | – Not described |
Switching from paper or another app
From paper, nothing has to be imported: keep honouring the paper cards your regulars carry until they fill, and start each customer on the digital card at their next visit. From another app, Rewardfinity imports members from a CSV file in the dashboard. Each row needs an email; the importer also reads name, points, lifetime points and joined date, takes up to 1,000 members in a batch, and shows a preview before anything is written.
- Stamp progress does not import. There is no stamp-count column, so move progress across as a points balance, or let customers finish the cards they already hold.
- Every member needs an email. Customers known to your old app only by a phone number re-join from your new QR code.
Our pick for an independent café: Rewardfinity
We make Rewardfinity, so weigh this accordingly. For a café that wants a stamp card now and a prepaid coffee pack or points later, it is where we would start: a stamp card and a prepaid pack among its eight card types, a native Square connection, a counter on a phone you already own, and 60 days to try it without a card.
If you want a branded ordering app on Square, a card in the customer’s phone wallet, a device customers tap at the counter, or a free start at one café, the “may suit” lines above point the way. To see the numbers behind a café’s card and reward, read the coffee shop loyalty guide, or look at your city: London, New York and Sydney each have a page.
Questions people ask
What is the best loyalty app for a coffee shop?
For an independent café that wants a stamp card now and may add a prepaid coffee pack or points later, we think it is Rewardfinity, and we make it, so weigh that: up to 100 stamps a card, a prepaid pack of up to 500 uses, native Square, and a 60-day trial with no card. For a branded ordering app on Square, look at Per Diem; for a wallet card, Loopy Loyalty; for a free start at one café, BaristaCard.
What should a café look for in a coffee rewards app?
Four things, in this order. The reward: a stamp card for the regular who buys a drink a day, and a prepaid pack for the one who buys in bulk. The till: whether the app connects to the one you already use, as Rewardfinity does with Square for a payment that carries the customer’s email. The customer’s side: whether a first visit needs a download or only a link or QR code. And what the reward gives away. Illustrative example — not a customer result: a free $5.00 drink after ten paid ones returns $5.00 ÷ (10 × $5.00) = 10% of sales. A café loyalty app that answers all four is the one to try first, and ours starts with a 60-day trial with no card.
How does a prepaid coffee pack work?
The café sets the number of uses and the price, takes payment in its own register, and staff confirm it before the uses are added to the customer’s card; each cup then uses one. Illustrative example — not a customer result: a pack of 10 drinks sold for $40.00, where each drink is $5.00 on the menu, is 10 × $5.00 = $50.00 of drinks, so the customer saves $10.00, or 20%, and the café has $40.00 before the first cup. Rewardfinity records the balance and every use; it never holds the money.
Does a coffee shop loyalty app work with Square?
Some do. Rewardfinity connects to Square natively: a payment carrying the customer’s email, or a Square customer record with one, earns for that member, and a new email is enrolled. A payment with no email is not matched, so staff scan the member’s QR code. Per Diem’s loyalty runs through Square Loyalty, and Loopy Loyalty documents Square through two Zapier automations on a paid Zapier plan. Stamp Me’s help centre says it does not integrate with POS systems.
Do customers need to download an app for a coffee shop loyalty card?
Not with Rewardfinity: customers join from a link or QR code and use a hosted member card in the browser, with no app download and no Rewardfinity password. Loopy Loyalty cards are Wallet passes, and BaristaCard says no app download is required. Per Diem builds a branded app for each café, and its web ordering needs no download for a first-time customer.
Is there a free loyalty app for a coffee shop?
Yes, in some. BaristaCard says a café’s first venue is free forever. Rewardfinity’s web product has no free plan: it starts with a 60-day trial with no card and no automatic charge, and if you do not choose a plan by the end, new earning, spins and redemptions pause and your records stay. Rewardfinity’s Shopify app has a Free plan with three active discount rewards.
How many stamps should a coffee shop loyalty card have?
Work back from what the reward gives away. Illustrative example — not a customer result: with drinks at $5.00 and a free drink after ten paid ones, the shop gives away $5.00 against 10 × $5.00 = $50.00 of sales, which is $5.00 ÷ $50.00 = 10%. An 8-stamp card gives away $5.00 ÷ $40.00 = 12.5%. Fewer stamps reward sooner and give back more. A Rewardfinity card can run to 100 stamps, with up to nine rewards along the way.
Run one stamp card at your counter.
Where web plans are on sale, a new workspace starts a 60-day trial with no card and no automatic charge. Set the stamp count, add a prepaid coffee pack if your regulars buy in bulk, and scan the first cards with a phone you already own. On Shopify, the app has a Free plan.